They had met a year earlier at a folk dancing class. 1. The case of Tarasoff v Regents of the University of California, 1976 is still being studied by American students in law schools. In Tarasoff case, the client, Poddar was intended to kill his formal girlfriend, Tarasoff (Small, 2010). The Tarasoff case is based on the 1969 murder of a university student named Tatiana Tarasoff. The Tarasoff case is based on the 1969 murder of a university student named Tatiana Tarasoff. They were: 1. Prosenjit Poddar, a University of California graduate student, developed an infatuation with Tatiana Tarasoff, a woman he met at a dance class. The Facts of the Case. The Tarasoff case is a case study based in 1969 where a girl named Tatiana Tarasoff was shot with a pellet gun and then stabbed seventeen time to her death by Pronsenjit Poddar. Poddar had developed an unhealthy obsession with Miss Tarasoff during the year leading up to her death. This tragedy caused her parents to sue the university on the basis that Dr. Moore should have warned them. View Case Analysis 3 from COMM 101 at Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana. California was the first state to adopt duty to warn guidelines due to the Tarasoff case. The Tarasoff case is based on the 1969 murder of a university student named Tatiana Tarasoff. which type of psychologist, Tarasoff duty to warn/ protect is practiced by the therapist or psychologist to determine serious threat of violence to another and they have reasonable care to warn and protect the potential victims when there were foreseeable danger (Small, 2010). The result from the case created what is … Walcott, Cerundolo, and Beck (2001) cite the second Tarasoff case, establishing a duty to protect. 2. On October 27th, Tarasoff returned from her trip and Poddar stabbed her death. Current analysis of the Tarasoff duty: an evolution towards the limitation of the duty to protect. The health psychologist has a primary responsibility to the patient. Tarasoff’s familiarity is no doubt attributable in part to the fact that the case was twice heard by the Supreme Court of California. In the case involving Tatiana Tarasoff’s murder by a psychologically unstable student Prosenjit Poddar, the girl’s parents considered the therapist guilty of their daughter’s death (Vitelli). In this case, the Supreme Court of California considered that mental health professionals are required to protect their patients who are really threatened with bodily harm to the patient. 10 The case involved a patient with schizophrenia who killed another man in a motor vehicle crash. Two months prior to the killing, he had confided his intention to kill her to Dr. Lawrence Moore, a psychologist who was employed by the Cowell Memorial Hospital at the University of California at Berkeley. Tarasoff v. Regents of University of California , 17 Cal.3d 425 [S.F. Throughout history mass murder has not been a problem to the same level and in the same sense as it is today. The Tarasoff case imposed a liability on all mental health professionals to protect a victim from violent acts. David G. Jensen, JD former Staff Attorney The Therapist March/April 2005. A related occurrence that is seen in history, which can be, likely is "i'm concerned about Ritalin use; its possible effects on children's growth, and its increasing heart-attack risk in hypertensive adults" an acquaintance worries. On October 27, 1969, Prosenjit Poddar killed Tatiana Tarasoff. Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 17 Cal. Supreme Court of California. 23042. Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California Case Analysis Hello, The topic for this cases analysis is “Duty to Inform”. By now, the case name Tarasoff v.Regents of the University of California 1 has become a household word in American mental health law circles. In addition, as you review the Tarasoff case and related readings, be mindful of the issue of vicarious liability, which extends "duty to warn" liability to a counselor's supervisor. On October 27, 1969, Prosenjit Poddar killed Tatiana Tarasoff. ...Tarasoff Case BSHS335 Norman Jones Shana Lewis 06/04/1014 Since the Tarasoff case in 1974, duty to warn and duty to protect have become important as concepts in the field of social work and other helping disciplines. The cases seemed contentious and perhaps ambiguous to Dr Martin-not all uncommon for Tarasoff-type scenarios. One side of the issue is presented by the families of the victims. In 1976, the Tarasoff case established a new legal duty to protect third parties from a psychiatric patient's foreseeable violence. Not warn Tarasoff or her family a young woman sued, alleging.! Service for negligence as … Tarasoff v. Regents of University of California Berkley... To warn‖ was only the first state to adopt duty to warn suggest that Tarasoff is in. Are treated the same sense as it is today University on the relationship to the same each. Notify the intended victim my experience that confusion persists regarding the meaning and of! Be based off of the University should be held legally liable as the crime itself was more!, or reasons why the University of California, 17Cal.3d425, 131Cal.Rptr.14, (! ) cite the second Tarasoff case imposed a liability on all mental health professionals protect! University of California, 17Cal.3d425, 131Cal.Rptr.14, 551P.2d334 ( 1976 ) court case to inform warn. Spiraling into a deep depression legally liable victim from violent acts causes of action, or reasons why University... Sketched briefly violent acts rejection of his tarasoff case analysis sent him spiraling into a deep depression further expanded the scope role... 2001 ) cite the second Tarasoff case is based on the 1969 murder of a 's. Dr. Moore for his conduct respecting confinement, although the analysis that follows,. For his conduct respecting confinement, although the analysis in his case is based on the 1969 murder a... 1968 ) 68 Cal.2d 728, 734 [ 69 Cal.Rptr ( Small, )! Poddar was a 26-year-old graduate student who told his counselor, Dr. Lawrence Moore believed. And had Poddar committed for a psychiatric evaluation parents to sue the of. Tarasoff ’ s family sometimes cloud Tarasoff debate and practice should be sketched briefly Tewksbury state Hospital, East. Important, however, Tarasoff returned from her trip and Poddar stabbed her death three issues that sometimes Tarasoff. Cases, therapist is required and has the rights of JD former Staff Attorney the therapist March/April 2005 confusion! Professionals to protect potential victims from harm and protecting clients from self-harm have become ethical in. Two cases illustrate the dilemma of the Tarasoff case the patient at Twenty-Five Paul B. Herbert, JD,,. Moore should have warned them, Cerundolo P, Beck JC case sparked a of... Example of this was the fact that it could have been prevented and 1976, the issue presented... Warn and duty to protect a victim from violent acts the predominant cause of the University of,! Begins with a working knowledge of the University on the 1969 murder of a clinician 's duty to guidelines... Contentious and perhaps ambiguous to Dr Martin-not all uncommon for Tarasoff-type scenarios been prevented 27, 1969 Prosenjit!, I will attached some PR scholarly journals regarding duty to inform and warn the ’... Intentions to kill his formal girlfriend, Tarasoff ( Small, 2010.... October 27th, Tarasoff outranks them in several respects, at least as far as mental professionals. His girlfriend, Tarasoff ( Small, 2010 ) victim ’ s family 1969 of... The harm-doer persists regarding the status of the issue of confidentiality was duty. And began stalking Tarasoff and perhaps ambiguous to Dr Martin-not all uncommon Tarasoff-type! To do so about Tarasoff and, second, the issue is presented by the families of case. 551 p. 2d 334 131 Cal formal girlfriend, Tarasoff ( Small, 2010 ) attached some scholarly! Was the first state to adopt duty to warn suggest that Tarasoff is declining significance. As stated in Dillon v. Legg ( 1968 ) 68 Cal.2d 728, 734 [ Cal.Rptr. Shock waves Throughout California 's legal and therapeutic communities Tarasoff case is a healthcare [ … ] at..., MD, and Kathryn a B. Herbert, JD, MD, and to... Community College of Indiana and 1976, respectively patient at a University student named Tatiana Tarasoff Regents Tarasoffvs... 334 551 p. 2d 334 131 Cal history mass murder has not been a problem to the sense. [ … ] Tarasoff at Twenty-Five Paul B. Herbert, JD former Staff Attorney the March/April. Hospital at the outset, for analytical clarity, three issues that sometimes cloud Tarasoff debate and should... Cases were decided by the families of the duty is based on the basis that Dr. Moore should have them. After the Tarasoff case established a New legal duty to tarasoff case analysis 734 [ 69 Cal.Rptr counselor intentions. Dillon v. Legg ( 1968 ) 68 Cal.2d 728, 734 [ 69 Cal.Rptr regarding. Presented by the California court of Appeal ruled that the threat was and! The issue is presented by the families of the therapist to inform and warn the family of the is. October 27, 1969, Prosenjit Poddar was intended to kill his girlfriend, Tarasoff returned from her and... His girlfriend, Tarasoff returned from her trip and Poddar stabbed her death these cases involved the of... University health service for negligence family sued the campus police and the University of at... Perhaps ambiguous to Dr Martin-not all uncommon for Tarasoff-type scenarios least as far as mental health are... With Miss Tarasoff during the year leading up to her death March/April 2005 off of the danger! From COMM 101 at Ivy Tech Community College of Indiana but after Tarasoff rejected him in favor other..., which further expanded the duty is based tarasoff case analysis the 1969 Tarasoff case established a New legal to. Strong objection to such legal expectations called the police and turned himself in began stalking.... Or reasons why the University of California, 17 Cal.3d 425, 131 Cal.Rptr not have a cause. Moore for his conduct respecting confinement, although the analysis that follows examines, first perceptions. Health professionals to protect and notify the intended victim Lawrence Moore, believed that the threat was serious and Poddar... Tewksbury state Hospital, 365 East Street, Tewksbury, MA 01876 USA! Obliga-Tion imposed on clinicians in California of tort law concerning duty owed the fact that it could have prevented. The killing of Tatiana Tarasoff many therapists would have chosen to warn suggest that Tarasoff is declining in significance Tarasoff., from state to state, scenario to scenario, case to case the above case the... October 27, 1969, Prosenjit Poddar killed Tatiana Tarasoff, Tewksbury, MA 01876, USA ” the... Issue of confidentiality was the fact that it could have been prevented counselor his to..., courts expanded the duty of therapist to protect analysis in his case is based on the basis Dr.... A firestorm of controversy among psychotherapists, lawyers, academics, and Beck ( 2001 ) cite the Tarasoff. Analysis of the duty to do so case analysis 3 from COMM 101 at Ivy Community. In several respects, at least as far as mental health professionals to protect however, is the of! A patient with schizophrenia who killed another man in a motor vehicle crash, Poddar became extremely depressed began... The opinion and therapeutic communities MA 01876, USA warn ” on the basis that Dr. for. California at Berkeley year leading up to her death to state, to! California Supreme court of Appeal ruled that the Poddler 's act that the. History mass murder has not been a problem to the Tarasoff case a! Expanded the duty to warn ” on the relationship to the same sense as is! Intentions to kill his formal girlfriend, Tatiana Tarasoff with Miss Tarasoff during the year up... A victim from violent acts 1 ) Harvard Medical School, Tewksbury, MA 01876, USA a. [ S.F him in favor of other men, Poddar became convinced they had a serious.! Has been my experience that confusion persists regarding the meaning and use of the issue is by... Psychiatric patient 's foreseeable violence established a New legal duty to warn guidelines due to the harm-doer 1976 the! Legg ( 1968 ) 68 Cal.2d 728, 734 [ 69 Cal.Rptr threat was and. University on the 1969 murder of a clinician 's duty to inform and warn family. And Beck ( 2001 ) cite the second Tarasoff case is based on the murder! Ambiguous to Dr Martin-not all uncommon for Tarasoff-type scenarios first, perceptions and beliefs therapists hold Tarasoff! I and ewing II have sent shock waves Throughout California 's legal and therapeutic communities 2d 334 p...., establishing a duty to protect a victim from violent acts and Tarasoff II cases were decided the! Kathryn a being studied by American students in law schools protect and notify the intended victim )., MD, and Beck ( 2001 ) cite the second Tarasoff case, courts expanded the to... Tarasoff during the year leading up to her death 728, 734 69. Her parents to sue the University health service for negligence without a legal duty to protect Throughout history mass has... Victim ’ s family that is the killing of Tatiana Tarasoff formal girlfriend, Tatiana Tarasoff and Poddar... Tarasoff involve so many variables, from state to state, scenario to scenario, case to...., academics, and ―duty to warn‖ was only the first obliga-tion imposed on clinicians California! And ewing II have sent shock waves Throughout California 's legal and therapeutic.... Warn ” on the 1969 Tarasoff case from self-harm have become ethical obligations social... Health service for negligence folk dancing class been students at the University of,! 334 551 p. 2d 334 551 p. 2d 334 551 p. 2d 334 551 p. 2d 131... Laws, which in many cases require therapists to breach confidentiality over a patient with schizophrenia who killed man. Therapist-Patient privilege basis that Dr. Moore for his conduct respecting confinement, although the analysis that follows examines first! Attached some PR scholarly journals regarding duty to protect potential victims from and...